How Providing Insurance Can Increase Repeat Revenue In Your Online Marketplace

October 19th, 2023 | 12 min read

Poshmark's Posh Protect (their insurance product) is a superhero in the fashion world, swoopingin to save the day with its trust-building powers. Batman and Robin rolled into one stylish package!

With Posh Protect, buyers can shop with the confidence of a seasoned fashionista. They know that they won't get ripped off by any nefarious sellers. For them, it's like having a personal shopper and a bodyguard all in one.

With Posh Protect, buyers can shop with the confidence of a seasoned fashionista. They know that they won't get ripped off by any nefarious sellers. For them, it's like having a personal shopper and a bodyguard all in one.

And for sellers, Posh Protect is like having a superhero sidekick. They get protected from the evil forces of shipping mishaps and lost packages. It's like having the Hulk on your side, ready to smash any obstacles.

Thanks to Posh Protect, the fashion marketplace has never been safer. A fortress of fashion.

Thanks to Posh Protect, the fashion marketplace has never been safer. A fortress of fashion.

No more worrying about receiving a sad, wrinkled shirt or a pair of shoes that look like they've been through a warzone. With Posh Protect, fashion mishaps are a thing of the past.

Who wouldn't want that? So why talk about online marketplace insurance?

Insurance is the safety net that keeps everyone from falling into their financial pit of despair. You can't avoid it, but you can make it work.

Insurance is the safety net that keeps everyone from falling into their financial pit of despair. You can't avoid it, but you can make it work.

For online marketplace operators, it's a great way to reduce liability. It's your superhero's shield, protecting you from the perils of the marketplace.

Plus, you've got the bonus of increased revenue! Who doesn't love making a little extra cash?

By offering insurance options, online marketplace operators generate additional streams of revenue. A pot of gold at the end of the rainbow – except it's a pot of money from insurance fees.

By offering insurance options, online marketplace operators generate additional streams of revenue. A pot of gold at the end of the rainbow – except it's a pot of money from insurance fees.

Offering insurance options can also lead to increased customer loyalty.

Customers love feeling safe and protected, and offering insurance is like giving them a warm, fuzzy blanket to wrap themselves in.

When it comes to online marketplaces, trust is everything. If your customers can't trust you, then your marketplace is as good as doomed. Insurance can change that.

When it comes to online marketplaces, trust is everything. If your customers can't trust you, then your marketplace is as good as doomed. Insurance can change that.

So if you're a marketplace operator who wants to:

  • Reduce liability
  • Increase revenue
  • Build customer loyalty

Then insurance is something to explore.

Let's take the example of TCGplayer, which uses insurance in its online marketplace offerings.

For TCGplayer, it's a world of collectible card games – where the stakes are high, and the cards are fragile. You could be left with a damaged card and a broken heart with one wrong move.

TCGplayer has got your back, in any case. With their Buyer Safeguard policy (insurance), you rest assured that your precious cards are protected during transit. It's like having a bodyguard for your cards, ready to jump in if anything goes wrong!

Shipping can be a nightmare – lost packages, damaged goods, enough to make anyone go crazy. But with TCGplayer's insurance coverage, they help say goodbye to shipping woes.

Insurance says hello to peace of mind. It's like having a therapist for your shipping anxiety. Always ready to listen and provide a comforting shoulder to lean on.

Insurance says hello to peace of mind. It's like having a therapist for your shipping anxiety. Always ready to listen and provide a comforting shoulder to lean on.

But the benefits of shipping insurance don't stop there. TCGplayer has built trust between buyers and sellers by offering buyer and seller protection.

Insurance is a mediator in a heated argument – a neutral party to settle disputes.

TCGplayer created a harmonious environment for all. And who doesn't love a little trust and harmony in their life?

Plus, it improved customer satisfaction and retention. Happy customers equals repeat business, and repeat business equals increased revenue.

For TCGplayer, insurance like having a money tree that keeps giving – except it's not a tree, it's their TCGplayer's Buyer Safeguard policy.

For TCGplayer, insurance like having a money tree that keeps giving – except it's not a tree, it's their TCGplayer's Buyer Safeguard policy.

Create Your Own Marketplace Fast

  • Launch your own marketplace niche fast
  • Easily connect your own domain name
  • Create your own categories quickly
  • Create custom fields specific to your requirements

Boost Repeat Revenue with Secure Sales in Your Online Marketplace

Increased trust is one of the reasons providing insurance in your online marketplace can increase repeat revenue.

By providing insurance, you're offering your customers an extra layer of protection, which can increase their trust in your platform.

Imagine:

  • Customers feel more at ease and secure while purchasing on your platform
  • The potential increase in positive reviews, satisfied customers and sellers
  • The satisfaction you feel knowing that your platform provides trustworthy services

Now, you might be thinking:

  • Offering insurance on your online marketplace sounds costly and time-consuming!
  • What about potential legal and administrative hurdles?
  • What kind of fees should I charge?

Yes, there can be complications, but at the same time, there are partners out there who can partner with you to make things easier. You don't have to do it all yourself. More to that some other time though.

Increasing trust is essential:

  • 67% of shoppers are willing to trust a transaction on a familiar online marketplace. Even if they don't know the seller of the product. (WeDevs)
  • 89% of consumers are more likely to make another purchase when they have a positive customer experience. (Salesforce). Insurance helps with that.
  • 83% of customers feel a sense of loyalty to brands that resolve their complaints. (Khoros). Get the shipping right!

An online marketplace that provides insurance to increase trust is Turo, a peer-to-peer car-sharing platform.

Turo offers third-party liability insurance up to $750,000 to its hosts, collision insurance up to the car's actual cash value, and protection against theft and damage caused by renters.

Turo has seen significant growth in recent years. In 2020, the company reported having over 10 million registered users. It had expanded its services to over 5,500 across the US, Canada, the UK, and Germany.

The company also expanded its services to Australia in 2022. As part of this, Turo's insurance policy has been a key factor in building trust with its users.

Want to implement insurance?

Offering Insurance Increases Repeat Revenue Because it Prevents Disintermediation

You know what they say - disintermediation is a fancy way of saying "cutting out the middleman."

It's like asking your friend to set you up on a date, but instead, you just go straight to the source and ask them out yourself. No more middleman messing things up for you!

But watch out for your online marketplaces! Disintermediation is a sneaky threat that can creep up on you when you least expect it.

But watch out for your online marketplaces! Disintermediation is a sneaky threat that can creep up on you when you least expect it.

Kind of like when your cat decides to knock over a vase in the middle of the night - you didn't see it coming. Still, suddenly there's a mess everywhere, and you're not sure how to clean it up (seriously).

One way to fight back is insurance! Just imagine "Insurance Man" is flying in here to protect buyers and sellers from all the risks and dangers of the online world.

With insurance, buyers and sellers can feel secure while using online marketplaces. Insurance is like the security guard at a fancy party - you can let loose and have fun, knowing that someone's got your back if things get out of hand.

With insurance, buyers and sellers can feel secure while using online marketplaces. Insurance is like the security guard at a fancy party - you can let loose and have fun, knowing that someone's got your back if things get out of hand.

With a bit of insurance, online marketplaces can prevent disintermediation and establish themselves as the go-to platform for buying and selling online.

And it's not that hard to convince your users to use insurance. Why wouldn't you want to use it:

  • One in three American consumers reported having experienced at least one of their parcels stolen (CNBC).
  • 73% of the victims of package theft were able to receive a refund eventually. (C+R Research).

Heard of StubHub? They use insurance to avoid disintermediation. StubHub is like the virtual ticket scalper but without the sketchy guy in the trench coat!

They've got this thing called the FanProtect Guarantee! The superhero cape for your ticket purchase. It swoops in to save the day if anything goes wrong, ensuring that you get valid tickets and protecting you from any issues that might pop up. Kind of like Batman as your personal ticket-buying assistant.

But it's not just the buyers who benefit. The sellers on StubHub get to sit back and relax, like a cool cucumber on a hot summer day.

But it's not just the buyers who benefit. The sellers on StubHub get to sit back and relax, like a cool cucumber on a hot summer day.

They don't have to worry about communicating with buyers or handling payments. StubHub does it all for them. It's your personal assistant, except instead of coffee runs, they take care of your ticket sales (and let's be real, that's way cooler).

Thanks to the FanProtect Guarantee, StubHub has established itself as a trustworthy and dependable platform for buying and selling tickets online.

And because of this, StubHub has avoided getting the boot from the ticket-selling game. Unlike some other online platforms (cough Craigslist cough).

Create a Competitive Advantage by Providing Insurance in Your Online Marketplace

You know what they say, offering insurance in the online marketplace is like putting a security guard at the door - it's the ultimate way to keep the riff-raff out.

Customers want to feel safe and secure when they're doing business online. Insurance coverage is like a warm hug that says, "we've got your back."

Customers want to feel safe and secure when they're doing business online. Insurance coverage is like a warm hug that says, "we've got your back."

It's like having a bouncer at a nightclub - people feel more comfortable knowing someone's there to handle any potential issues.

And it's not just about making customers feel warm and fuzzy inside. Offering insurance coverage can also give your online marketplace a competitive edge.

Want to strap a rocket to your car and leave all the other vehicles (competitors) in the dust? Customers are likelier to choose your platform over others if they know they're getting the added insurance coverage protection.

You can attract new customers like bees to honey by providing insurance coverage in your online marketplace. It's like throwing a party and having everyone show up because they know it will be a good time.

You can attract new customers like bees to honey by providing insurance coverage in your online marketplace. It's like throwing a party and having everyone show up because they know it will be a good time.

People love feeling secure, and insurance coverage is the force field that protects them from any potential losses. Your fairy godmother - you know you're in good hands.

Insurance coverage can also increase customer retention. Once customers know your platform has the added protection, they want to stick around.

So if you want to give your online marketplace a competitive advantage? Keep your customers happy by offering insurance.

  • ~ 30% of consumers listed the ability to easily return their items as their number one reason for shopping online. (Oberlo)
  • 1 lousy customer experience would be enough for 76% of consumers to discontinue their business with a company. (Venture Beat)

Grailed also offers insurance on their marketplace.

Grailed is like a virtual thrift store but without the musty smell and the awkward small talk with the cashier (no, please, no).

Grailed is a marketplace for buying and selling men's and women's clothing, and they've got this thing called Grailed Purchase Protection.

You won't be left high and dry if your item doesn't appear or isn't as described in the listing. Grailed Purchase Protection is your fashion guardian angel.

You won't be left high and dry if your item doesn't appear or isn't as described in the listing. Grailed Purchase Protection is your fashion guardian angel.

And not just the buyers benefit from Grailed's Purchase Protection. Sellers can breathe a sigh of relief knowing that they're covered too.

Grailed handles all the communication and payment, so sellers can relax while the money rolls in. Your personal shopper, except instead of picking out clothes for you, they take care of your sales.

In part to Grailed's Purchase Protection, they've gained a competitive advantage in the fashion resale industry. They have that stylish secret weapon that no one else has.

Customers are drawn to the added layer of protection that Grailed provides. Something that sets them apart from other online marketplaces. It's that killer accessory that takes your outfit to the next level.

Customers are drawn to the added layer of protection that Grailed provides. Something that sets them apart from other online marketplaces. It's that killer accessory that takes your outfit to the next level.

By offering insurance coverage, Grailed has not only attracted new customers, but they've also increased customer retention.

Want to implement insurance? Consider these items when implementing insurance:

  • Identify risk areas within your online marketplace that could benefit from insurance.
  • Risky areas to consider could include shipping, fraud, or product liability.
  • Train your customer support team to handle any insurance-related questions.
  • Monitor the effectiveness of the insurance policy by tracking customer feedback.
  • Continuously evaluate and improve your insurance policy.

Closing Summary

So what's new? Providing insurance coverage can have a significant impact on your repeat revenue! It's like having an invisible shield that protects your sales from harm.
 
When buyers and sellers have trust, they're more likely to stick around and keep using your platform. And who doesn't want loyal customers? It's your bunch of little helpers who always have your back.

When buyers and sellers have trust, they're more likely to stick around and keep using your platform. And who doesn't want loyal customers? It's your bunch of little helpers who always have your back.

Plus, offering insurance coverage can prevent disintermediation. No, it's not a new medical condition - it just means that buyers and sellers can go directly to each other without using your platform.
 
Disintermediation is like your buyers having a new love interest and leaving you behind. But with insurance coverage, buyers and sellers are likelier to stick with your platform and keep those transactions coming. The magic love potion that keeps your customers coming back for more.
 
The same about the competitive advantage that insurance coverage can provide. It's could be that secret weapon that your competitors don't have.

The same about the competitive advantage that insurance coverage can provide. It's could be that secret weapon that your competitors don't have.

When you offer that added layer of protection, customers are more likely to choose your platform over others. You still have the coolest toy in the playground - everyone wants to play with it.
 
Insurance coverage can encourage larger transactions, giving your customers a little push to go big or go home. They'll take that leap and make a larger purchase when they know they're protected. The cheerleader is the insurance coverage (but it comes without the pom-poms).
 
Reducing transactional friction is also a huge benefit of offering insurance coverage. Your insurance offering is part of smoothing out all the bumps in the road.
 
Customers are happier and more likely to return when everything is running smoothly. You're the wizard who can make all the transactional problems disappear.

Customers are happier and more likely to return when everything is running smoothly. You're the wizard who can make all the transactional problems disappear.

So that's it. Providing insurance coverage can be a valuable investment for your online marketplace. It's like having a trusty sidekick who's always there to help you out.
 
Insurance coverage allows you to differentiate yourself from competitors, attract new customers, and increase repeat revenue. You might have hit a jackpot but without all the flashing lights and ringing bells.
 
How about you?

  • Have you used buyer protection insurance from an online marketplace?
  • Does insurance in an online marketplace make you more likely to buy from them?
  • Do you sell in an online marketplace with seller protection?

Want to learn more? Learn how Escrow can drive online sales or how much commission online marketplaces take from buyers and sellers.

Create Your Own Marketplace Fast

  • Launch your own marketplace niche fast
  • Easily connect your own domain name
  • Create your own categories quickly
  • Create custom fields specific to your requirements

The Online Marketplace Platform

Create your online marketplace in a day

Join thousands of Yclas users and create your marketplace website